Pet Supplies from Local Shops in Brooklyn, NY (Page 17)

Discover curated pet supplies from independent neighborhood boutiques in Brooklyn, NY. Currently tracking 1,436 listings with a median price of $23 (typical range $16–$48).

1,436 items

Brooklyn Market Snapshot

Regional median $50 · IQR $22–$150 · Snapshot November 19, 2026
View full Brooklyn Market Report →

Market statistics reflect the full regional observation dataset across all tracked sources, independent of the active discovery filter.

Pill Buddy Naturals
$18.99
Pill Buddy Naturals
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Rolled Leather Collar, Black
$32.99
Rolled Leather Collar, Black
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Pet Shampoo and Conditioner 2-in-1,  Dog Wood
$21.99
Pet Shampoo and Conditioner 2-in-1, Dog Wood
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Pom Pom Knit Sweater - Ivory
$48
Pom Pom Knit Sweater - Ivory
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Chuck It Pro Launcher 25"
$19.99
Chuck It Pro Launcher 25"
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Harborside Twilight Hand Woven Collar
$48
Harborside Twilight Hand Woven Collar
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Harry Otter
$22.99
Harry Otter
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Dog Dad Hat Olive
$28.99
Dog Dad Hat Olive
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Lilac Dye Denim Stretch Vest
$8.99
Lilac Dye Denim Stretch Vest
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Colorblock Merino Wool Sweater, Olive
$84.99
Colorblock Merino Wool Sweater, Olive
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Slow Feeder in Terra, 4 sizes
$62.99
Slow Feeder in Terra, 4 sizes
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Bumi, 2 sizes
$19.99
Bumi, 2 sizes
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Beef Burger - 1 piece
$2.99
Beef Burger - 1 piece
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Farm Fresh Cat Toys - 3pk
$12.99
Farm Fresh Cat Toys - 3pk
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Black Freedom Harness & Leash
$49.99
Black Freedom Harness & Leash
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Blue Quilted Nylon Puffer Jacket with Shearling Lining
$85
Blue Quilted Nylon Puffer Jacket with Shearling Lining
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Pb&J Sandwich - Snuffle Dog Toy
$16.99
Pb&J Sandwich - Snuffle Dog Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Marigold Flower Bandana, 3 Sizes
$20
Marigold Flower Bandana, 3 Sizes
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Muffy Cuddler, Himalayan
$124.99
Muffy Cuddler, Himalayan
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Fuzzy Textured Knit Sweater, Heather Blue
$36.99
Fuzzy Textured Knit Sweater, Heather Blue
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Kong Better Buzz Banana
$8.99
Kong Better Buzz Banana
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Rock Candy Scent Enrichment Toy
$8.99
Rock Candy Scent Enrichment Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Soufflé Pet Bowl - Amber Orange
$68.99
Soufflé Pet Bowl - Amber Orange
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Orange Leather Leash
$58.99
Orange Leather Leash
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Small Batch Freeze Dried Diner Sliders 14oz, 5 flavors
$40.99
Small Batch Freeze Dried Diner Sliders 14oz, 5 flavors
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Earth Animal No Hide Venison Stix, 1.6oz
$12.99
Earth Animal No Hide Venison Stix, 1.6oz
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Desert Horizon Pet TeePee
$89.99
Desert Horizon Pet TeePee
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Caramel Pebble Leather Collar
$8
Caramel Pebble Leather Collar
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Cobalt Pebble Leather Collar
$8
Cobalt Pebble Leather Collar
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Stella & Chewy’s Freeze Dried Dinner Patties- Beef
$36.99
Stella & Chewy’s Freeze Dried Dinner Patties- Beef
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
XS Easy Double Bowl Feeder in Pale Green Stainless Steel
$158
XS Easy Double Bowl Feeder in Pale Green Stainless Steel
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Bulk Biscuit By Pound
$11.99
Bulk Biscuit By Pound
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Blue Hearts Bandana, 3 Sizes
$20
Blue Hearts Bandana, 3 Sizes
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Pupsicle Treat Tray Mold Treat Dispenser, 2 sizes
$12.99
Pupsicle Treat Tray Mold Treat Dispenser, 2 sizes
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Fresh Breath Oral Care Kit Small
$18.99
Fresh Breath Oral Care Kit Small
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Peanut Chipmunk
$17.99
Peanut Chipmunk
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Hairball Cinnamon Whisky Cat Toy
$10.99
Hairball Cinnamon Whisky Cat Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Freeze Dried Wild Salmon Cubes
$17.99
Freeze Dried Wild Salmon Cubes
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Creamy Peanut Butter & Banana Treat
$12.99
Creamy Peanut Butter & Banana Treat
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
NYC Lady Liberty
$14.99
NYC Lady Liberty
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast