Food & Groceries from NYC Local Shops (Page 31)

Explore food & groceries curated from independent NYC neighborhood shops. Currently tracking 4,930 listings with a median price of $13 (typical range $8–$23).

4,930 items
2025 Yesica Moreno; Finca El Rosal, Chiroso - New Season, 1st Harvest - Colombia
$24.50
2025 Yesica Moreno; Finca El Rosal, Chiroso - New Season, 1st Harvest - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
The Matcha
$38 Sold Out
The Matcha
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
One Trick Pony Unsalted Peanut Butter
$13.19
One Trick Pony Unsalted Peanut Butter
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB PUMPKIN SPICE
$9.50
1/2-LB PUMPKIN SPICE
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Armando Hurtado; Los Pinos - Peru
$28.75
2025 Armando Hurtado; Los Pinos - Peru
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Ardor Olive Oil
$40 Sold Out
Ardor Olive Oil
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Nugo Dark Chocolate Mint Chip Bar
$2.74
Nugo Dark Chocolate Mint Chip Bar
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT NICARAGUAN SHG
$10.50
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT NICARAGUAN SHG
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Rene Arellanos Ore; Garancalqui - Peru
$26
2025 Rene Arellanos Ore; Garancalqui - Peru
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Salted Caramel Sauce
$12 Sold Out
Salted Caramel Sauce
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Heydey Pinto Simply Perfect
$5.49
Heydey Pinto Simply Perfect
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
COCONUT
$18.99
COCONUT
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Mbature Family; Kamavindi Estate, Field Blend - Kenya
$27
2025 Mbature Family; Kamavindi Estate, Field Blend - Kenya
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Queens SF Gochujang
$16 Sold Out
Queens SF Gochujang
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Olli Salumeria Chedd N Cracker
$6.59
Olli Salumeria Chedd N Cracker
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB NAIROBI BLEND
$10
1/2-LB NAIROBI BLEND
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Lucio Luque - Peru
$28.25
2025 Lucio Luque - Peru
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Tinned Fish Riches Box
$130 Sold Out
Tinned Fish Riches Box
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Native Forest Organic Unsweetened Simple Coconut Milk
$5.49
Native Forest Organic Unsweetened Simple Coconut Milk
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB FRENCH MOCHA JAVA
$9.50
1/2-LB FRENCH MOCHA JAVA
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Jose Martinez; El Casino, 2nd Harvest - Colombia
$25
2025 Jose Martinez; El Casino, 2nd Harvest - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
The Minnow Tinned Fish Set
$46 Sold Out
The Minnow Tinned Fish Set
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Behave Gummy Stars, 1.8oz
$5.49
Behave Gummy Stars, 1.8oz
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB FRENCH COSTA RICAN TARRAZU
$9.50
1/2-LB FRENCH COSTA RICAN TARRAZU
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Anibal Sanchez Burbano; La Siria - Colombia
$30.25
2025 Anibal Sanchez Burbano; La Siria - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Roscioli Balsamic Vinegar
$40 Sold Out
Roscioli Balsamic Vinegar
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Honeymoon Chocolate Honeycomb
$17.37
Honeymoon Chocolate Honeycomb
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB ITALIAN ESPRESSO
$9.50
1/2-LB ITALIAN ESPRESSO
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Oliva Quinayas; Villa Sofia - Colombia
$24.50
2025 Oliva Quinayas; Villa Sofia - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Big Night Cookie Tin
$60 Sold Out
Big Night Cookie Tin
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Nana Joes Swell Coconut, Pistachios
$4.94
Nana Joes Swell Coconut, Pistachios
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB SWP DECAF TOASTED ALMOND
$11.50
1/2-LB SWP DECAF TOASTED ALMOND
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Juan Jiménez; El Porvenir, New Season - Colombia
$25
2025 Juan Jiménez; El Porvenir, New Season - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sold Out
Condiment Queen Box
$105 Sold Out
Condiment Queen Box
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Built Coconut Puff Bar
$4.39
Built Coconut Puff Bar
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB SWP DECAF PECAN
$11.50
1/2-LB SWP DECAF PECAN
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Bukeye; Musumba Hill - Burundi
$25
2025 Bukeye; Musumba Hill - Burundi
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Better Than Bouillon Base Beef OG
$10.44
Better Than Bouillon Base Beef OG
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB SWP DECAF ORANGE
$11.50
1/2-LB SWP DECAF ORANGE
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Victor Dota - Ecuador
$32.50
2025 Victor Dota - Ecuador
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee