Pet Supplies from NYC Local Shops (Page 32)

Explore pet supplies curated from independent NYC neighborhood shops. Currently tracking 1,515 listings with a median price of $22 (typical range $15–$47).

1,515 items
Sold Out
Fizzy Cola Plush Toy
$15.99 Sold Out
Fizzy Cola Plush Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Earth Worm Toy
$12.99 Sold Out
Earth Worm Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Vital Cat Minnows
$9.99 Sold Out
Vital Cat Minnows
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Deli Cup Knit Toy
$16.99 Sold Out
Deli Cup Knit Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Leather Collar in Grey
$6 Sold Out
Leather Collar in Grey
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Kitten Mittens
$12.99 Sold Out
Kitten Mittens
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Found Classic Cotton Harness | Radish
$46.99 Sold Out
Found Classic Cotton Harness | Radish
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Silly Stix Cat Toy
$10.99 Sold Out
Silly Stix Cat Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Sleepypod Air Travel Carrier Charcoal
$249.99 Sold Out
Sleepypod Air Travel Carrier Charcoal
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Undercoat Deshedder Tool
$22.99 Sold Out
Undercoat Deshedder Tool
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Holiday Burrow - Gingerbread House
$19.99 Sold Out
Holiday Burrow - Gingerbread House
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Acadia National Park Mat
$64.99 Sold Out
Acadia National Park Mat
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Pompom Caterpillar
$12.99 Sold Out
Pompom Caterpillar
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Strategy Game Snuffle Mat
$29.99 Sold Out
Strategy Game Snuffle Mat
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Extra Strength Ball
$26.99 Sold Out
Extra Strength Ball
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
The Cherry Red No-Pull Harness
$39.99 Sold Out
The Cherry Red No-Pull Harness
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
The Bouquet No-Pull Harness
$39.99 Sold Out
The Bouquet No-Pull Harness
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Black Tower Pet Food Bowl, Tall
$79.99 Sold Out
Black Tower Pet Food Bowl, Tall
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup Chewy Box
$12.99 Sold Out
Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup Chewy Box
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Two of Hearts Toy
$12.99 Sold Out
Two of Hearts Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
White Dove Rope Leash
$58.99 Sold Out
White Dove Rope Leash
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Front Range Harness - Campfire Orange
$19.99 Sold Out
Front Range Harness - Campfire Orange
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
GOOD AT NAPS Throw Blanket
$128 Sold Out
GOOD AT NAPS Throw Blanket
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Chicken Little Treats, 2oz tube
$7.49 Sold Out
Chicken Little Treats, 2oz tube
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Blush Pebble Leather Collar
$8 Sold Out
Blush Pebble Leather Collar
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Cedarwood + Sage Shampoo
$21.99 Sold Out
Cedarwood + Sage Shampoo
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Angel Wings Costume
$26.99 Sold Out
Angel Wings Costume
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Georgia Gator Plush Toy
$22.99 Sold Out
Georgia Gator Plush Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Freeze Dried Duck Neck - 1 piece
$4.99 Sold Out
Freeze Dried Duck Neck - 1 piece
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Midnight No-Pull Harness
$39.99 Sold Out
Midnight No-Pull Harness
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Pinecone Rubber Toy, 4 inches
$19.99 Sold Out
Pinecone Rubber Toy, 4 inches
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Silicone Placemat, Pink
$18.95 Sold Out
Silicone Placemat, Pink
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Burger Plush Toy
$16.99 Sold Out
Burger Plush Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Coconut Dog Twists, 12 Pack
$12.99 Sold Out
Coconut Dog Twists, 12 Pack
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Berry & Cream Soft Chewy Biscuits
$10.99 Sold Out
Berry & Cream Soft Chewy Biscuits
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Lucy Camp Out Bandana
$22.99 Sold Out
Lucy Camp Out Bandana
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Inca Alpaca
$21.99 Sold Out
Inca Alpaca
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Eye Ball Wool Toy
$7.99 Sold Out
Eye Ball Wool Toy
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Dog Dad Hat Blue
$28.99 Sold Out
Dog Dad Hat Blue
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Sold Out
Vital Cat Chicken Hearts
$9.99 Sold Out
Vital Cat Chicken Hearts
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast