Secondhand Shoes in NYC & NJ (Page 12)

Browse secondhand shoes across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 856 listings with a median price of $50 (typical range $25–$100).

856 items
New Balance 990v6 Grey Sneakers Size 9.5
$90
New Balance 990v6 Grey Sneakers Size 9.5
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Timberland "Wheat" Boots
$28
Timberland "Wheat" Boots
Melrose, The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Nike Blazer Low '77 Patchwork Sneakers
$40
Nike Blazer Low '77 Patchwork Sneakers
Queens, NY
Karrot
French Toast Girls Mary Jane Shoes Black Size 5
$18
French Toast Girls Mary Jane Shoes Black Size 5
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Assorted Nike Air Jordan Sneakers 8 Pairs Size 5Y, 4.5Y
$202
Assorted Nike Air Jordan Sneakers 8 Pairs Size 5Y, 4.5Y
Queens, NY
Karrot
Assorted Men's Sneakers Lot
$360
Assorted Men's Sneakers Lot
Queens, NY
Karrot
Sparkly black rhinestone knee high boots
$180
Sparkly black rhinestone knee high boots
Queens, NY
Karrot
Women’s Woven Elastic Slip-On Comfort Sneakers - Size 9
$30
Women’s Woven Elastic Slip-On Comfort Sneakers - Size 9
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Elite Backpack
$12
Nike Elite Backpack
Arverne, Queens, NY
Karrot
Veja V-10 White Sneakers
$38
Veja V-10 White Sneakers
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan 4 Retro Shoes
$75
Air Jordan 4 Retro Shoes
Queens, NY
Karrot
Crocs Shoes Size J1
$20
Crocs Shoes Size J1
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Vans Old Skool Stackform Suede/Canvas 1.5 inch Platform Sneakers
$51
Vans Old Skool Stackform Suede/Canvas 1.5 inch Platform Sneakers
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
TOMS x Paper Source Avocado Shoes Youth 3.5
$28
TOMS x Paper Source Avocado Shoes Youth 3.5
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
MAUI & Sons Skate shoes
$10
MAUI & Sons Skate shoes
Queens, NY
Karrot
White "FASHION SPORTS" Sneakers
$15
White "FASHION SPORTS" Sneakers
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Lebron Witness 8 'Light Crimson' FB229-600 Men's 8.5
$77
Nike Lebron Witness 8 'Light Crimson' FB229-600 Men's 8.5
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Trade or Offers Amiri Shoes with box
Free
Trade or Offers Amiri Shoes with box
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan 6 Pink/Black/Red Sneakers
$150
Air Jordan 6 Pink/Black/Red Sneakers
Queens, NY
Karrot
Black athletic shoes with white accents
$6
Black athletic shoes with white accents
Queens, NY
Karrot
Jordan 6 Rings Men's Basketball Shoes
$120
Jordan 6 Rings Men's Basketball Shoes
Queens, NY
Karrot
Bundle Black Boots (3pairs)
$100
Bundle Black Boots (3pairs)
Elmhurst, Queens, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan 5 "Racer Blue" Sneakers
$27
Air Jordan 5 "Racer Blue" Sneakers
Queens, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Jordan 4 Retro Bred
$340
Nike Air Jordan 4 Retro Bred
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Black Chunky Sneakers
$15
Black Chunky Sneakers
Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Black Ankle Boots
$23
Black Ankle Boots
Queens, NY
Karrot
Louis Vuitton Sneakers
$180
Louis Vuitton Sneakers
Queens, NY
Karrot
Nike Dunk High SE sneakers
$50
Nike Dunk High SE sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Brown Faux Leather Ankle Boots with Side Zippers
$18
Brown Faux Leather Ankle Boots with Side Zippers
Queens, NY
Karrot
Adidas Campus Shoes Pink US 8.5
$36
Adidas Campus Shoes Pink US 8.5
Queens, NY
Karrot
Adidas Predator Club FG/MG Soccer Cleats
$45
Adidas Predator Club FG/MG Soccer Cleats
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Black Heeled Knee-High Boots, size 6M (85)
$15
Black Heeled Knee-High Boots, size 6M (85)
Queens, NY
Karrot
IVORY SNAKE Combat Boots
$44
IVORY SNAKE Combat Boots
Hudson County, NJ
Karrot
Santa Fe Boot Co. Tan Fringe Cowboy Boots
$55
Santa Fe Boot Co. Tan Fringe Cowboy Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Authentic Nike Bodega Dunk High Sneakers
$286
Authentic Nike Bodega Dunk High Sneakers
Queens, NY
Karrot
Ralph Lauren Boys Casual Boots [Size 6] [PREOWNED/CLEAN]
$3
Ralph Lauren Boys Casual Boots [Size 6] [PREOWNED/CLEAN]
Queens, NY
Karrot
Steve Madden Women's LUCA-D Denim Fab Boots
$70
Steve Madden Women's LUCA-D Denim Fab Boots
Richmond Hill, Queens, NY
Karrot
Massimo Dutti Women's Dress Shoes⚽️
$150
Massimo Dutti Women's Dress Shoes⚽️
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Adidas Martial Arts Shoes, Size 9 (84)
$15
Adidas Martial Arts Shoes, Size 9 (84)
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Sneaker
$52
Sneaker
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot