Secondhand Shoes in NYC & NJ (Page 16)

Browse secondhand shoes across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 856 listings with a median price of $50 (typical range $25–$100).

856 items
Naturalizer Nona Wide Calf Knee-High Boots - New
$40
Naturalizer Nona Wide Calf Knee-High Boots - New
Queens, NY
Karrot
black wedges & gold heel
$10
black wedges & gold heel
East Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Pelotón bike shoes  size 38
$42
Pelotón bike shoes size 38
Central Park, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
MENS SHOE LOT!
$77
MENS SHOE LOT!
Jackson Heights, Queens, NY
Karrot
Fratelli Rosetti  original Italian oxford shoes
$20
Fratelli Rosetti original Italian oxford shoes
Hudson Yards, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
HOKA Rocket X 2 Running Shoes
$60
HOKA Rocket X 2 Running Shoes
Kew Gardens, Queens, NY
Karrot
UGG Suede Platform Lace-Up Shoes size 7
$60
UGG Suede Platform Lace-Up Shoes size 7
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Assorted Women's Sandals and Heels Collection
$35
Assorted Women's Sandals and Heels Collection
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot
Sperry x Aritzia Leather Boat Shoes
$50
Sperry x Aritzia Leather Boat Shoes
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Prada Sneakers
$350
Prada Sneakers
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
🏈 Nike Air Jordan 2 Retro Low Sneakers
$81
🏈 Nike Air Jordan 2 Retro Low Sneakers
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Bottega Veneta Silver Metallic Mesh Running Shoes
$350
Bottega Veneta Silver Metallic Mesh Running Shoes
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Lot of Sneakers and Boots
$115
Lot of Sneakers and Boots
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
6 expensive brand name shoes..size 9.5
$100
6 expensive brand name shoes..size 9.5
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Margate Beige Form Running Sneakers Casual Slip on Shoes
$16
Margate Beige Form Running Sneakers Casual Slip on Shoes
Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Steve Madden Rhinestone Loafers Size 10.5
$100
Steve Madden Rhinestone Loafers Size 10.5
Forest Hills, Queens, NY
Karrot
NIKE DUNK LOW (PANDA) (GS)
$48
NIKE DUNK LOW (PANDA) (GS)
Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Women's Glitter Boots
$20
Women's Glitter Boots
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Jordan Air Jordan 6 Men's Mid Top Colorblock Sneakers
$125
Jordan Air Jordan 6 Men's Mid Top Colorblock Sneakers
Borough Park, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Black Shoes
$32
Adidas Black Shoes
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Black Steve madden sneakers
$92
Black Steve madden sneakers
Far Rockaway, Queens, NY
Karrot
Paisley white GIVENCHY SNEAKERS
$259
Paisley white GIVENCHY SNEAKERS
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Filling Pieces Low Top Sneakers - Light Pink Suede
$19
Filling Pieces Low Top Sneakers - Light Pink Suede
Jackson Heights, Queens, NY
Karrot
Puma x Fenty Creeper Sneakers Tan
$124
Puma x Fenty Creeper Sneakers Tan
Ozone Park, Queens, NY
Karrot
Puma White Sneakers
Free
Puma White Sneakers
Pomonok, Queens, NY
Karrot
Nike x Supreme Air Force 1 Low
$90
Nike x Supreme Air Force 1 Low
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Supreme x Nike Air Force 1 Low White
$90
Supreme x Nike Air Force 1 Low White
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
New Pony Women's Top Star White/Blue Sneakers 8.5
$40
New Pony Women's Top Star White/Blue Sneakers 8.5
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Chanel Sneakers – Authentic
$600
Chanel Sneakers – Authentic
Midtown East, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike dunk low topology size 10
$120
Nike dunk low topology size 10
Jamaica, Queens, NY
Karrot
Reformation Terra Sneaker
$50
Reformation Terra Sneaker
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 V2 & Nike Jordan Sneakers Bundle
$145
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 V2 & Nike Jordan Sneakers Bundle
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Dunk Low White Sneakers
Free
Nike Dunk Low White Sneakers
Pomonok, Queens, NY
Karrot
Jordan 4 Retro KAWS Cool Grey Sneakers
$1,000
Jordan 4 Retro KAWS Cool Grey Sneakers
Queens, NY
Karrot
Reebok Forte Lounger Sneakers - Women's Size 7
$35
Reebok Forte Lounger Sneakers - Women's Size 7
Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 Sneakers
$60
Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 Sneakers
Fordham, The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Max 97 Black Sneakers
$64
Nike Air Max 97 Black Sneakers
Jamaica Hills, Queens, NY
Karrot
Size 5 Black Leather Knee-High Boots with Claw Accents
$23
Size 5 Black Leather Knee-High Boots with Claw Accents
Mott Haven, The Bronx, NY
Karrot
NEW Women's Kenneth Cole Black Leather Knee-High Boots
$35
NEW Women's Kenneth Cole Black Leather Knee-High Boots
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Women's Red Knee-High Boots
$20
Women's Red Knee-High Boots
Lenox Hill, Manhattan, NY
Karrot