Pet Supplies for Sale in Brooklyn, NY

Discover pet supplies deals and quality items listed by local neighbors in Brooklyn, NY. Buy and sell locally with 0% listing fees, direct in-app chat, and safe neighborhood pickup on Moonoh.

1,432 items

Brooklyn Market Snapshot

Regional median $50 · IQR $22–$150 · Snapshot November 19, 2026
View full Brooklyn Market Report →

Market statistics reflect the full regional observation dataset across all tracked sources, independent of the active discovery filter.

Hot Dog Everything Picks
$36
Hot Dog Everything Picks
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Collarless Jacket
$248
Collarless Jacket
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Locating Girlhood: Place and Identity in Early American “Schoolgirl” Art
$60
Locating Girlhood: Place and Identity in Early American “Schoolgirl” Art
Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Salter House
Cat Food Candle
$15.99
Cat Food Candle
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Lip butter balm, rose petal
$10
Lip butter balm, rose petal
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, NY
Rue Saint Paul
Holiday Dog Collar Bow Blue Plaid – Large
$26.99
Holiday Dog Collar Bow Blue Plaid – Large
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Dog Tumbler
$35
Dog Tumbler
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Big Collar Wool Jacket
$698
Big Collar Wool Jacket
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
The Collected Peter Pan (Oxford World's Classics Hardback Collection)
$21.95
The Collected Peter Pan (Oxford World's Classics Hardback Collection)
Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Salter House
Ken The Cat Desk Calendar 2027
$16.99
Ken The Cat Desk Calendar 2027
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Can I pet your dog hat
$36
Can I pet your dog hat
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, NY
Rue Saint Paul
Holiday Dog Collar Bow Red Plaid – Large
$26.99
Holiday Dog Collar Bow Red Plaid – Large
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Round Collar Herringbone Jacket
$278
Round Collar Herringbone Jacket
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Sold Out
The Companion Species Manifesto: Dogs, People, and Significant Otherness (Paradigm)
$12.95 Sold Out
The Companion Species Manifesto: Dogs, People, and Significant Otherness (Paradigm)
Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Salter House
American Shorthair Gray Cat Ornament
$29.99
American Shorthair Gray Cat Ornament
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Sold Out
Frankie cat eye sunglasses
$85 Sold Out
Frankie cat eye sunglasses
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, NY
Rue Saint Paul
Holiday Dog Collar Bow Hanukkah – Large
$26.99
Holiday Dog Collar Bow Hanukkah – Large
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Stand Collar Patterned Shirt
$278
Stand Collar Patterned Shirt
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Sold Out
Peter and Wendy or Peter Pan (Wisehouse Classics Anniversary Edition of 1911 - with 13 original illustrations)
$37 Sold Out
Peter and Wendy or Peter Pan (Wisehouse Classics Anniversary Edition of 1911 - with 13 original illustrations)
Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Salter House
My Gift To You Cat Butt Mug
$16.99
My Gift To You Cat Butt Mug
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Sold Out
Forget me not catchall plate, light blue
$38 Sold Out
Forget me not catchall plate, light blue
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, NY
Rue Saint Paul
Chestnut Leopard Bone
$24.99
Chestnut Leopard Bone
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Band Collar Cotton Shirt
$348
Band Collar Cotton Shirt
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Sold Out
The Tale of Ginger and Pickles (Peter Rabbit)
$8.99 Sold Out
The Tale of Ginger and Pickles (Peter Rabbit)
Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Salter House
Ping Hatta Sticker - Tarot Cat The Hermit
$4.99
Ping Hatta Sticker - Tarot Cat The Hermit
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Sold Out
Military liner, cord collar
$250 Sold Out
Military liner, cord collar
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, NY
Rue Saint Paul
Football
$16.99
Football
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Neroli & Petitgrain Body Soap
$38
Neroli & Petitgrain Body Soap
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Merry Bright Cat Holiday Card
$6.99
Merry Bright Cat Holiday Card
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Sadie Bear
$34.99
Sadie Bear
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Dogs Ornament
$16
Dogs Ornament
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Hanukkah Fat Cat Holiday Card
$6.99
Hanukkah Fat Cat Holiday Card
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Trax Moose
$34.99
Trax Moose
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Big Collar Wool Coat
$528
Big Collar Wool Coat
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Holiday Black Cat Small Gift Bag 7"
$6.99
Holiday Black Cat Small Gift Bag 7"
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Highline Dog Feeder - Green
$129
Highline Dog Feeder - Green
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
14k Gold Dog Charm
$268
14k Gold Dog Charm
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store
Holiday Black Cat Gift Bag 9.5"
$7.99
Holiday Black Cat Gift Bag 9.5"
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Friends NYC
Highline Dog Feeder - Orange
$129
Highline Dog Feeder - Orange
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Love Thy Beast
Stand Collar Plaid Shirt
$448
Stand Collar Plaid Shirt
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Front General Store

Showing 1–40 of 1,432 items