Food & Groceries from NYC Local Shops (Page 22)

Explore food & groceries curated from independent NYC neighborhood shops. Currently tracking 4,930 listings with a median price of $13 (typical range $8–$23).

4,930 items
2025 Wilson Alba; Sierra Morena, New Season - Colombia
$27.50
2025 Wilson Alba; Sierra Morena, New Season - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Julep Strainer
$26
Julep Strainer
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Castello Havarti Dill Cheese
$13.19
Castello Havarti Dill Cheese
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
VANILLA BEAN
$18.99
VANILLA BEAN
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Flor Marina Betancourt; Finca Cataluña - Colombia
$25.50
2025 Flor Marina Betancourt; Finca Cataluña - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Anchovies in Extra Virgin Olive Oil (Set of 2)
$21
Anchovies in Extra Virgin Olive Oil (Set of 2)
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Campo Grande Iberico Bacon
$16.49
Campo Grande Iberico Bacon
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
SWP DECAF COSTA RICAN
$19.99
SWP DECAF COSTA RICAN
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Crispilliano Contreras x Lost Origin - Panama
$90
2025 Crispilliano Contreras x Lost Origin - Panama
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Zesty Sansho Peppercorn Miso
$13
Zesty Sansho Peppercorn Miso
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Cocojune Sour Cream
$8.79
Cocojune Sour Cream
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
ESPRESSO CENT'ANNI
$19.99
ESPRESSO CENT'ANNI
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Francy Burbano; Buena Vista, New Season - Colombia
$27.50
2025 Francy Burbano; Buena Vista, New Season - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Mackerel Fillets with Thyme and Lemon
$14
Mackerel Fillets with Thyme and Lemon
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Violife Vegan Feta
$10.44
Violife Vegan Feta
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT SUMATRA Grade 1 Mandheling
$11
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT SUMATRA Grade 1 Mandheling
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Elora; Lot #156 - Ethiopia
$25
2025 Elora; Lot #156 - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Rosi's Hot Oil
$16
Rosi's Hot Oil
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Happier 16oz Golden Milk
$10.44
Happier 16oz Golden Milk
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
ORGANIC FT FRENCH SUMATRA Grade 1 Mandheling
$21.99
ORGANIC FT FRENCH SUMATRA Grade 1 Mandheling
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Gildardo & Yolanda Lopez; El Calamar, New Season - Colombia
$27
2025 Gildardo & Yolanda Lopez; El Calamar, New Season - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Tinned Vegetable Trio
$42
Tinned Vegetable Trio
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
South Mountain 32oz Whole Milk
$6.04
South Mountain 32oz Whole Milk
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
KATE'S BLEND
$18.99
KATE'S BLEND
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Gerbota - Ethiopia
$25
2025 Gerbota - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Olive Brine
$8
Olive Brine
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Hawthorn Valley Ginger Carrots Organic
$12.09
Hawthorn Valley Ginger Carrots Organic
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
SWP DECAF HOLIDAY BLEND
$19.99
SWP DECAF HOLIDAY BLEND
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Jair Arles Galindez; El Guayabo, New Season - Colombia
$27.50
2025 Jair Arles Galindez; El Guayabo, New Season - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sky High Strawberry Jam
$22
Sky High Strawberry Jam
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Organic Valley Salted Butter
$16.49
Organic Valley Salted Butter
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT BLACK & TAN BLEND
$10.50
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT BLACK & TAN BLEND
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Maritza Dota, Late - Ecuador
$30.50
2025 Maritza Dota, Late - Ecuador
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Everyday Cuvée Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$35
Everyday Cuvée Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Oh Snap! Dill Pickle Bites
$2.74
Oh Snap! Dill Pickle Bites
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT ESPRESSO
$10.50
1/2-LB ORGANIC FT ESPRESSO
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Yaye Chericho - Ethiopia
$25
2025 Yaye Chericho - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Pure Kosher Sea Salt
$13
Pure Kosher Sea Salt
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Minnow Sardines In Olive Oil
$13.19
Minnow Sardines In Olive Oil
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
SWP DECAF ORGANIC PERU
$22.99
SWP DECAF ORGANIC PERU
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.