Food & Groceries from NYC Local Shops (Page 23)

Explore food & groceries curated from independent NYC neighborhood shops. Currently tracking 4,930 listings with a median price of $13 (typical range $8–$23).

4,930 items
2025 Koko; Lot #159, Washed - Ethiopia
$25.50
2025 Koko; Lot #159, Washed - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Club Big Night FALL Pantry Box
$150
Club Big Night FALL Pantry Box
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Maxines Heavenly Cookie Pnut Btr Choc Chnk
$9.89
Maxines Heavenly Cookie Pnut Btr Choc Chnk
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB FRENCH PAPUA NEW GUINEA GRADE 1
$9.50
1/2-LB FRENCH PAPUA NEW GUINEA GRADE 1
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Eduar Moriones Garcia; Finca Brisa - Colombia
$27
2025 Eduar Moriones Garcia; Finca Brisa - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Candy Cane Everything Picks
$36
Candy Cane Everything Picks
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Hu Chocolate Crunchy Mint
$7.69
Hu Chocolate Crunchy Mint
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
SWP DECAF VIENNA COLOMBIAN SUPREMO
$21.99
SWP DECAF VIENNA COLOMBIAN SUPREMO
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Tamiru Tadesse Tesema; Alo Village, White Honey - Ethiopia
$27.50
2025 Tamiru Tadesse Tesema; Alo Village, White Honey - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Lucesca Olive Oil
$44
Lucesca Olive Oil
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Jacob Mixed Berry Bar
$6.59
Jacob Mixed Berry Bar
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
FRENCH ITALIAN ESPRESSO
$18.99
FRENCH ITALIAN ESPRESSO
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Tamiru Tadesse Tesema; Alo Village, Washed - Ethiopia
$27
2025 Tamiru Tadesse Tesema; Alo Village, Washed - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Island Creek Tinned Fish Trio
$46
Island Creek Tinned Fish Trio
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Republic of Vermont Raw Honey
$25.29
Republic of Vermont Raw Honey
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
FRENCH CINNAMON
$18.99
FRENCH CINNAMON
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 La Familia Moreno; La Sierra - Honduras
$27.50
2025 La Familia Moreno; La Sierra - Honduras
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Island Creek x Mariscadora Mussels in Pickled Sauce
$14
Island Creek x Mariscadora Mussels in Pickled Sauce
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Hampton Grocer Super Seed Granola
$14.29
Hampton Grocer Super Seed Granola
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
JAMAICAN BLUE MOUNTAIN
$106
JAMAICAN BLUE MOUNTAIN
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Finca Sophia; Lots FS9025 & FS9325 - Panama
$80
2025 Finca Sophia; Lots FS9025 & FS9325 - Panama
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Yuzu Marmalade
$15
Yuzu Marmalade
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Matriark Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce
$11.54
Matriark Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
MEXICALI CREME
$18.99
MEXICALI CREME
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Duwancho - Ethiopia
$25
2025 Duwancho - Ethiopia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Badger Flame Beets Tin
$15
Badger Flame Beets Tin
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Cravings Creamy Tomato Sauce
$16.27
Cravings Creamy Tomato Sauce
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
ORGANIC FT ETHIOPIAN YIRGACHEFFE
$21.99
ORGANIC FT ETHIOPIAN YIRGACHEFFE
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 David Berrio; La Casita, New Season - Colombia
$25.50
2025 David Berrio; La Casita, New Season - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Sweet Prince Tomato Tin
$15
Sweet Prince Tomato Tin
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Cabi Original Japanese Mayo
$10.99
Cabi Original Japanese Mayo
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
ORGANIC FT MEXICAN CHIAPAS
$20.99
ORGANIC FT MEXICAN CHIAPAS
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Octavio Rueda; El Mirador, 2nd Harvest - Colombia
$26
2025 Octavio Rueda; El Mirador, 2nd Harvest - Colombia
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Roscioli Aged Balsamic Vinegar
$50
Roscioli Aged Balsamic Vinegar
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
BUDDY BUDDY Peanut Butter
$13.19
BUDDY BUDDY Peanut Butter
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB AMARETTO
$9.50
1/2-LB AMARETTO
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.
2025 Arturo Paz; El Itacayo - Honduras
$31
2025 Arturo Paz; El Itacayo - Honduras
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
SEY Coffee
Herb-Infused Pizza Oil
$25
Herb-Infused Pizza Oil
Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY
Big Night
Traditional Medicinals Organic tea Lemon Balm
$9.34
Traditional Medicinals Organic tea Lemon Balm
SoHo, Manhattan, NY
Happier Grocery
1/2-LB CHOCOLATE CHERRY
$9.50
1/2-LB CHOCOLATE CHERRY
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Porto Rico Importing Co.