Secondhand Shoes in Brooklyn, NY

Browse verified secondhand shoes listed by local neighbors and community marketplaces in Brooklyn, NY. Currently tracking 125 listings with a median price of $40 (typical range $25–$70).

125 items

Brooklyn Market Snapshot

Regional median $50 · IQR $22–$150 · Snapshot November 19, 2026
View full Brooklyn Market Report →

Market statistics reflect the full regional observation dataset across all tracked sources, independent of the active discovery filter.

Vans Old Skool Red/Cream Suede Sneakers - 11.5
$45
Vans Old Skool Red/Cream Suede Sneakers - 11.5
Crown Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
UGG Women's Dakota Slippers/Size 7 (가격내림)
$35
UGG Women's Dakota Slippers/Size 7 (가격내림)
Brooklyn, NY
HeyKorean
See by Chloe sandals
$40
See by Chloe sandals
Brooklyn, NY
HeyKorean
New Balance Fresh Foam X Lav V2 (Women's size 8)
$40
New Balance Fresh Foam X Lav V2 (Women's size 8)
Crown Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Boys Black Spider Web Sneakers
$5
Boys Black Spider Web Sneakers
Brownsville, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Saucony Women's Running Shoes Black and Silver
$98
Saucony Women's Running Shoes Black and Silver
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
New Puma Court Sneaker - Women's Size 8.5
$48
New Puma Court Sneaker - Women's Size 8.5
Canarsie, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Reebok Men's Shoes Gray
$64
Reebok Men's Shoes Gray
Canarsie, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Vomero 5 Sneakers Size 3Y
$38
Nike Vomero 5 Sneakers Size 3Y
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Jordan Brand "23" Full Zip Hoodie
$75
Jordan Brand "23" Full Zip Hoodie
Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Quilted Bomber Jacket
$160
Nike Quilted Bomber Jacket
Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Assorted Women's Shoes - Various Brands
$150
Assorted Women's Shoes - Various Brands
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Reebok sneakers size 8
$40
Reebok sneakers size 8
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Elite Backpack
$92
Nike Elite Backpack
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Steve Madden P-Tyson slip-on Dress Loafers Size 9
$40
Steve Madden P-Tyson slip-on Dress Loafers Size 9
East Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
New Balance 990v6 Men's Sneakers
$135
New Balance 990v6 Men's Sneakers
Fort Greene, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Vans Classic Slip-On Black Canvas Shoes
$60
Vans Classic Slip-On Black Canvas Shoes
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Black Over-the-Knee Boots with Chunky Soles
$7
Black Over-the-Knee Boots with Chunky Soles
East New York, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Dunk Low Teal Orange White Shoes new new ds
$75
Nike Dunk Low Teal Orange White Shoes new new ds
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Capezio - Black Leather Lace-Up Tap Shoes
$10
Capezio - Black Leather Lace-Up Tap Shoes
East New York, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
New Balance 1000 Sneakers Pink
$90
New Balance 1000 Sneakers Pink
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Jordan 6 Retro Sneakers
$80
Nike Air Jordan 6 Retro Sneakers
Red Hook, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
New Balance Running Shoes
$100
New Balance Running Shoes
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Balenciaga Track Sneakers Black Size 43
$150
Balenciaga Track Sneakers Black Size 43
Kensington, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Black Platform Knee-High Boots
$45
Black Platform Knee-High Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Black Patent Platform Shoes
$12
Black Patent Platform Shoes
East New York, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Coutgo Womens Dress Shoes Vintage Cutout Pumps
$30
Coutgo Womens Dress Shoes Vintage Cutout Pumps
Midwood, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Women’s glitter shoes
$11
Women’s glitter shoes
Marine Park, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Doritos Flamin' Hot Men's Ground Up Comfort Slide Sandals 10
$30
Doritos Flamin' Hot Men's Ground Up Comfort Slide Sandals 10
Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Non-Slip Multi-Purpose Pool and Sea Shoes 6-8 Big Kid Tropical F
$10
Non-Slip Multi-Purpose Pool and Sea Shoes 6-8 Big Kid Tropical F
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Response Cushion Sneakers White/Silver
$40
Adidas Response Cushion Sneakers White/Silver
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
New Balance Sneakers Men's 12
$40
New Balance Sneakers Men's 12
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Intimidation Sneakers 11.5
$45
Adidas Intimidation Sneakers 11.5
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Axcess Mens Formal Dress Shoes Size 11
$25
Axcess Mens Formal Dress Shoes Size 11
East Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike P-6000 Men's Running Shoes
$110
Nike P-6000 Men's Running Shoes
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Stacy Adams black and white wingtip shoes
$45
Stacy Adams black and white wingtip shoes
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Yeezy Foam Runner Shoes Size 275
$41
Adidas Yeezy Foam Runner Shoes Size 275
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Steve Madden Black Patent Boots Size 5
$35
Steve Madden Black Patent Boots Size 5
Dyker Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Crocs Shoes Size J1
$20
Crocs Shoes Size J1
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
TOMS x Paper Source Avocado Shoes Youth 3.5
$28
TOMS x Paper Source Avocado Shoes Youth 3.5
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot

Showing 1–40 of 125 items