Secondhand Shoes in Brooklyn, NY (Page 3)

Browse verified secondhand shoes listed by local neighbors and community marketplaces in Brooklyn, NY. Currently tracking 125 listings with a median price of $40 (typical range $25–$70).

125 items

Brooklyn Market Snapshot

Regional median $50 · IQR $22–$150 · Snapshot November 19, 2026
View full Brooklyn Market Report →

Market statistics reflect the full regional observation dataset across all tracked sources, independent of the active discovery filter.

Kids Steve Madden size 1 winter boot
$50
Kids Steve Madden size 1 winter boot
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Coach Leah Platform Zip Boots
$140
Coach Leah Platform Zip Boots
Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
👟 WHOLE SNEAKER COLLECTION FOR SALE — PRICES NEGOTIABLE
Price in store
👟 WHOLE SNEAKER COLLECTION FOR SALE — PRICES NEGOTIABLE
Downtown Brooklyn, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan Black Bookbag backpack
$10
Air Jordan Black Bookbag backpack
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Guess Women's Fur Lined Boots - Size 9
$15
Guess Women's Fur Lined Boots - Size 9
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Olive Green Chunky Sole Boots
$14
Olive Green Chunky Sole Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Sparkly Silver Platform Boots
$45
Sparkly Silver Platform Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
“🧡” Dr. Martens 2976 Smooth Black Chelsea Boots
$60
“🧡” Dr. Martens 2976 Smooth Black Chelsea Boots
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Olive Green Chunky Platform Boots
$28
Olive Green Chunky Platform Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Khombu Women's Winter Boots
$15
Khombu Women's Winter Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Beautiful warm rain boots.
$12
Beautiful warm rain boots.
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Vans Old Skool White and Grey Sneakers
$35
Vans Old Skool White and Grey Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
On Running THE ROGER Clubhouse Sneakers
$80
On Running THE ROGER Clubhouse Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike SB Blazer Mid Dime Sneakers
$70
Nike SB Blazer Mid Dime Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Brooks Adrenaline GTS Running Shoes
$52
Brooks Adrenaline GTS Running Shoes
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Barreda Lo Sneakers US 8.5
$60
Adidas Barreda Lo Sneakers US 8.5
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Puma Ignite Elevate 2 Golf Shoes, White/Navy, Size 8 US
$50
Puma Ignite Elevate 2 Golf Shoes, White/Navy, Size 8 US
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
New Balance 480 Sneakers
$55
New Balance 480 Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Skechers Women's Black Sneakers Size 8.5
$45
Skechers Women's Black Sneakers Size 8.5
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Boys Vasque Hiking Boot Brown/Olive Color Size 5
$20
Boys Vasque Hiking Boot Brown/Olive Color Size 5
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Yeezy 700 V3 Safflower
$193
Adidas Yeezy 700 V3 Safflower
Gravesend, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Adidas Aeroready Slim Fit Track Pants Black
$20
Adidas Aeroready Slim Fit Track Pants Black
Kensington, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Stride Dri-FIT Running Top Medium
$20
Nike Stride Dri-FIT Running Top Medium
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike "PROVE THEM WRONG" Sneaker Poster Pop Art Wall Art
$999
Nike "PROVE THEM WRONG" Sneaker Poster Pop Art Wall Art
Borough Park, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Ecko Unltd. Blue Puffer Boots
$17
Ecko Unltd. Blue Puffer Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Dark Brown Knee-High Boots
$35
Dark Brown Knee-High Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Mix No. 6 Rocklyn Silver Glitter Leopard Combat Boots
$35
Mix No. 6 Rocklyn Silver Glitter Leopard Combat Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Women's Sporto Evelyn 2 Hiking Boots - Size 8M
$17
Women's Sporto Evelyn 2 Hiking Boots - Size 8M
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Lower East Side Black Slouch Boots
$9
Lower East Side Black Slouch Boots
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Bogs Women's Rain Boots, Size 8
$15
Bogs Women's Rain Boots, Size 8
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Kate Spade Keswick Sneakers Size 8.5B
$55
Kate Spade Keswick Sneakers Size 8.5B
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
OSYL Fashion Sport Sneakers
$25
OSYL Fashion Sport Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Shiny Red High-Top Sneakers
$10
Shiny Red High-Top Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Unlisted Crown Sneakers Size 8.5
$16
Unlisted Crown Sneakers Size 8.5
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Vans x Peanuts High Top Skate Shoes
$68
Vans x Peanuts High Top Skate Shoes
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
AVIA Custom SIZE 5Y Shoes $25
$25
AVIA Custom SIZE 5Y Shoes $25
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Altra Escalante Racer 2 Men's Running Shoes Black Size 11
$50
Altra Escalante Racer 2 Men's Running Shoes Black Size 11
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Skechers Relaxed Fit Shoes
$20
Skechers Relaxed Fit Shoes
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Merrell Moab 3 mens 8" Tactical cream Boots J004107 Sz 13
$90
Merrell Moab 3 mens 8" Tactical cream Boots J004107 Sz 13
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Foamposite Gold and Black Sneakers
$100
Nike Air Foamposite Gold and Black Sneakers
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot

Showing 1–120 of 125 items