Secondhand Shoes in Manhattan, NY (Page 2)

Browse verified secondhand shoes listed by local neighbors and community marketplaces in Manhattan, NY. Currently tracking 180 listings with a median price of $50 (typical range $28–$120).

180 items

Manhattan Market Snapshot

Regional median $22 · IQR $10–$75 · Snapshot November 19, 2026
View full Manhattan Market Report →

Market statistics reflect the full regional observation dataset across all tracked sources, independent of the active discovery filter.

Gold Snake Print Boots
$15
Gold Snake Print Boots
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike SB Dunk Low Pro Wizard of Oz Poppy Field Red F - Mens 10
$359
Nike SB Dunk Low Pro Wizard of Oz Poppy Field Red F - Mens 10
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Croft & Barrow Black Wedge Sandals
$15
Croft & Barrow Black Wedge Sandals
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Stacy Adams Black Loafer Shoes
$64
Stacy Adams Black Loafer Shoes
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Adidas Anthony Edward’s Low1 Size-12
$70
Adidas Anthony Edward’s Low1 Size-12
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Skechers Women's Grey Leopard Print Sneakers
$15
Skechers Women's Grey Leopard Print Sneakers
TriBeCa, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Size 13 sneakers
$37
Size 13 sneakers
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Moonstar CHIC INJECTION RALY VUL white sneakers 6M/27cm w Box
$30
Moonstar CHIC INJECTION RALY VUL white sneakers 6M/27cm w Box
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Moschino Bubble Teddy sneakers (men)
$220
Moschino Bubble Teddy sneakers (men)
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Balenciaga Runner Sneakers
$500
Balenciaga Runner Sneakers
Hudson Yards, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Birkenstock Gizeh Beach Thong Sandals Slippers Gold EU 41
$49
Birkenstock Gizeh Beach Thong Sandals Slippers Gold EU 41
Chelsea, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Max 97 Multi Pastel
$140
Nike Air Max 97 Multi Pastel
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Brown Leather Chelsea Boots
$18
Brown Leather Chelsea Boots
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Black Leather Knee-High Boots
$35
Black Leather Knee-High Boots
Upper East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
New Balance 530 White Pink Sneakers
$30
New Balance 530 White Pink Sneakers
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Adidas Climalite Gym Black T-Shirt Size L ptp 19"
$15
Adidas Climalite Gym Black T-Shirt Size L ptp 19"
Chelsea, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Vans Ultrarange EXO SE Sneakers Size 10.5
$51
Vans Ultrarange EXO SE Sneakers Size 10.5
East Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Women's Court Royale 2 Low Top Sneakers Women 5 or 35.5
$39
Nike Women's Court Royale 2 Low Top Sneakers Women 5 or 35.5
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Coach city sneakers
$34
Coach city sneakers
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Shoes
$32
Shoes
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Girl Toddler Sneakers & shoes
$20
Girl Toddler Sneakers & shoes
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Burberry Sneakers
$400
Burberry Sneakers
Hamilton Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
J.Crew Black Braided Heeled Sandals size 10
$43
J.Crew Black Braided Heeled Sandals size 10
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Puma MB.03 Not From Here Basketball Shoes
$94
Puma MB.03 Not From Here Basketball Shoes
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Foamposite One Shoes
$61
Nike Air Foamposite One Shoes
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Okabash sandals
$10
Okabash sandals
Midtown Manhattan, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan 14 Retro Yellow Sneakers
$300
Air Jordan 14 Retro Yellow Sneakers
Sugar Hill, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Dri-FIT Red & Black Camo Hoodie – XL 12 Yr old boy
$14
Nike Dri-FIT Red & Black Camo Hoodie – XL 12 Yr old boy
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Women's Suede Ankle Boots
$40
Women's Suede Ankle Boots
Lower East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Men's Red Lattice Cage Design Sport Sneakers Size EU 39 US 6.5e
$25
Men's Red Lattice Cage Design Sport Sneakers Size EU 39 US 6.5e
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Balenciga Running Shoes
$453
Balenciga Running Shoes
Lenox Hill, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Women’s Woven Elastic Slip-On Comfort Sneakers - Size 9
$30
Women’s Woven Elastic Slip-On Comfort Sneakers - Size 9
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Vans Old Skool Stackform Suede/Canvas 1.5 inch Platform Sneakers
$51
Vans Old Skool Stackform Suede/Canvas 1.5 inch Platform Sneakers
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
White "FASHION SPORTS" Sneakers
$15
White "FASHION SPORTS" Sneakers
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Jordan 4 Retro Bred
$340
Nike Air Jordan 4 Retro Bred
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Adidas Predator Club FG/MG Soccer Cleats
$45
Adidas Predator Club FG/MG Soccer Cleats
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Massimo Dutti Women's Dress Shoes⚽️
$150
Massimo Dutti Women's Dress Shoes⚽️
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Adidas Martial Arts Shoes, Size 9 (84)
$15
Adidas Martial Arts Shoes, Size 9 (84)
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nine West Black Suede Peep Toe Heels Size 9.5
$20
Nine West Black Suede Peep Toe Heels Size 9.5
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Max 2090 & Air Max 98 Sneakers
$60
Nike Air Max 2090 & Air Max 98 Sneakers
Manhattan, NY
Karrot

Showing 1–80 of 180 items