Secondhand Pet Supplies in NYC & NJ (Page 5)

Browse secondhand pet supplies across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 503 listings with a median price of $20 (typical range $10–$45).

503 items
Sold Out
물고기 어항용품 (인조수초, 청소용품, 필터, 베타 사료)
Price in store Sold Out
물고기 어항용품 (인조수초, 청소용품, 필터, 베타 사료)
Queens, NY
HeyKorean
6 cans senior dog food, expired 2028
$15
6 cans senior dog food, expired 2028
Ridgewood, Queens, NY
Karrot
NEW✨2027 Day-to-Day Calendar -Dog Shaming
$9
NEW✨2027 Day-to-Day Calendar -Dog Shaming
Midtown East, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Petmate gray and black plastic pet carrier
$45
Petmate gray and black plastic pet carrier
Holliswood, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pink Cat Ear Headphones
$12
Pink Cat Ear Headphones
Lower East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
PETFITS DOG PEN
$50
PETFITS DOG PEN
Kensington, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
MP Bergamo Bracco Travel 6 Pet Carrier
$73
MP Bergamo Bracco Travel 6 Pet Carrier
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
IMIPAW Automatic Pet Feeder
$18
IMIPAW Automatic Pet Feeder
Washington Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Dog crate
$49
Dog crate
Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Carrier
$20
Pet Carrier
Fort Greene, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Plush Pet Bed
$3
Plush Pet Bed
Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat 50x12in
$8
PetSafe ScatMat Indoor Pet Training Mat 50x12in
Glendale, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pawtners Heated Cat House for Multiple Cats
$70
Pawtners Heated Cat House for Multiple Cats
Middle Village, Queens, NY
Karrot
Dog soft cone collar  L size
$4
Dog soft cone collar L size
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot
Brand New Cat Tree Condo Tower
$35
Brand New Cat Tree Condo Tower
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Marc Fisher White Kitten Heel Mules
$19
Marc Fisher White Kitten Heel Mules
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
White Ceramic Pet Bowls with Bamboo Stand
$25
White Ceramic Pet Bowls with Bamboo Stand
Queens, NY
Karrot
AirTag Holder for Dog Collar, 4 Pack
$13
AirTag Holder for Dog Collar, 4 Pack
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Decorative Marble Cat
$10
Decorative Marble Cat
Queens, NY
Karrot
NEW✨HiJINX Bag Charm - Cat Keychain
$4
NEW✨HiJINX Bag Charm - Cat Keychain
Midtown East, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin Dog Food
$30
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin Dog Food
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
🔥 Brand NEW – Automatic Self-Cleaning Cat Litter Box, 90-L
$140
🔥 Brand NEW – Automatic Self-Cleaning Cat Litter Box, 90-L
Dyker Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
24-in-1 Multivitamin Chews for Dogs
$8
24-in-1 Multivitamin Chews for Dogs
Forest Hills, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Bling Dog Jacket & Cosmo Fur Babies Sweater
$15
Pet Bling Dog Jacket & Cosmo Fur Babies Sweater
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
OUTRAV Medium Folding Pet Cot
$16
OUTRAV Medium Folding Pet Cot
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Coach Signature Dog Collar
$68
Coach Signature Dog Collar
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Original oil Painting - Whimsical Cat and Figures
$50
Original oil Painting - Whimsical Cat and Figures
East Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Littlest Pet Shop Collection - 25 Figures
$50
Littlest Pet Shop Collection - 25 Figures
Jamaica, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pink Floral Pattern Indoor Pet Tent
$20
Pink Floral Pattern Indoor Pet Tent
Flushing, Queens, NY
Karrot
Colorful Balloon Dog Necklace
$4
Colorful Balloon Dog Necklace
Chelsea, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Puzzle Tornado – Intermediate Le
$8
Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Dog Puzzle Tornado – Intermediate Le
Financial District, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Animated Dogs Art Print
$4
Animated Dogs Art Print
Bath Beach, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nike Air Jordan 4 Retro Black Cat
$191
Nike Air Jordan 4 Retro Black Cat
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Red Lion Dance Pet Costume
$5
Red Lion Dance Pet Costume
Queens, NY
Karrot
Niwawa Ceramic Mug - Cat Design
$8
Niwawa Ceramic Mug - Cat Design
Queens, NY
Karrot
Arenero automático para gatos marca Kitten Mew
$160
Arenero automático para gatos marca Kitten Mew
Jackson Heights, Queens, NY
Karrot
Live Floating Aquarium plants | Betta & Tropical Fish
$5
Live Floating Aquarium plants | Betta & Tropical Fish
Lower East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
10 Dog Charms Puppy Pendants Assorted Lot Paw Print Antiqued Sil
$14.95
10 Dog Charms Puppy Pendants Assorted Lot Paw Print Antiqued Sil
Coney Island, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Playology Teething Bone for Dogs 50lbs+ Peanut Butter Scent
$9
Playology Teething Bone for Dogs 50lbs+ Peanut Butter Scent
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
New Keny Auto-Close Pressure Mounted Dog Gate
$30
New Keny Auto-Close Pressure Mounted Dog Gate
Midwood, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot

Showing 1–200 of 503 items