Secondhand Pet Supplies in NYC & NJ (Page 8)

Browse secondhand pet supplies across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 503 listings with a median price of $20 (typical range $10–$45).

503 items
Pink Cat Backpack Set with Lunch Bag and Pencil Case
$35
Pink Cat Backpack Set with Lunch Bag and Pencil Case
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Educational School Book Bundle
$10
Educational School Book Bundle
Queens, NY
Karrot
The Princeton Review MCAT Complete Test Prep Bundle
$100
The Princeton Review MCAT Complete Test Prep Bundle
Chelsea, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Cat Necklace Cute Gift Cat Neck Jewelry Personality
$15
Cat Necklace Cute Gift Cat Neck Jewelry Personality
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
FeelNeedy Automatic Cat Litter Box
$75
FeelNeedy Automatic Cat Litter Box
Soundview, The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Petmate Deluxe Vari Kennel Jr.
$18
Petmate Deluxe Vari Kennel Jr.
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Cat Scratching Post with Toys
$10
Cat Scratching Post with Toys
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
CAT S61 Rugged Smartphone Charged & Working
$214
CAT S61 Rugged Smartphone Charged & Working
Glendale, Queens, NY
Karrot
Tiny Tiger Chicken Recipe Pate Cat Food - 3 oz can
$1
Tiny Tiger Chicken Recipe Pate Cat Food - 3 oz can
Queens, NY
Karrot
Cat Toy Roller with Bells
$1
Cat Toy Roller with Bells
Far Rockaway, Queens, NY
Karrot
Amazon Basics 3-Tier Cat Cage Playpen - 22 Inch
$50
Amazon Basics 3-Tier Cat Cage Playpen - 22 Inch
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Petmaker® Multi-Level Cat Tree Condo
$35
Petmaker® Multi-Level Cat Tree Condo
Queens, NY
Karrot
52 Tubes Inaba Churu Cat Treats Variety Pack
$20
52 Tubes Inaba Churu Cat Treats Variety Pack
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
12-in-1 Cat Climber with Bridge and Hammock
$90
12-in-1 Cat Climber with Bridge and Hammock
Little Neck, Queens, NY
Karrot
Assorted Cat Food Treats and Wet Food Variety Pack
$22
Assorted Cat Food Treats and Wet Food Variety Pack
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Multi-Level Cat Tree with Plush Perches
$7
Multi-Level Cat Tree with Plush Perches
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Brand New Multi-Level Cat Tree with Hammock and Condo
$35
Brand New Multi-Level Cat Tree with Hammock and Condo
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Royal Canin Appetite Control Cat Food and Greenies Treats
$60
Royal Canin Appetite Control Cat Food and Greenies Treats
Queens, NY
Karrot
Gray Multi-Level Cat Tree with Scratching Post
$1
Gray Multi-Level Cat Tree with Scratching Post
Queens, NY
Karrot
Diamond Painting Kit - Cats & Butterflies - 40-30
$6
Diamond Painting Kit - Cats & Butterflies - 40-30
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Springer Sling Bag + Dog Leash
$28
Springer Sling Bag + Dog Leash
Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Dog Nail Scratch Board
$14
Dog Nail Scratch Board
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
2XL Dog Bed with Egg Crate Memory Foam
$40
2XL Dog Bed with Egg Crate Memory Foam
Middle Village, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Grooming Kit - Dog Clippers & Nail Grinder
$25
Pet Grooming Kit - Dog Clippers & Nail Grinder
Elmhurst, Queens, NY
Karrot
Cat grass blend
Free
Cat grass blend
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Sideshow Collectibles Black Cat Comiquette Felicia Hardy
$180
Sideshow Collectibles Black Cat Comiquette Felicia Hardy
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Feandrea gray multi-level cat tree
$28
Feandrea gray multi-level cat tree
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
I'm Roy Munchy Bone Bacon & Cheese Flavor Medium to Large Dogs
Free
I'm Roy Munchy Bone Bacon & Cheese Flavor Medium to Large Dogs
Palisades Park, Bergen County, NJ
Karrot
Heart to Tail Collapsible Ball Launcher Dog Toy
$10
Heart to Tail Collapsible Ball Launcher Dog Toy
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
LEGO Disney 101 Dalmatians Buildable Dog Set 43269
$120
LEGO Disney 101 Dalmatians Buildable Dog Set 43269
Queens, NY
Karrot
Special Kitty 20lb Fresh Scent Cat Litter
$10
Special Kitty 20lb Fresh Scent Cat Litter
Queens, NY
Karrot
Grey Felt Cat Bed Tent
Free
Grey Felt Cat Bed Tent
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Magic Cat Sweety masajeador egg mini
$10
Magic Cat Sweety masajeador egg mini
Queens, NY
Karrot
Sheba Perfect Portions Cat Food Variety Pack
$23
Sheba Perfect Portions Cat Food Variety Pack
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Jackson Galaxy large cat kicker toy
Free
Jackson Galaxy large cat kicker toy
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Omega 3 for Dogs Joint Support Soft Chews
$20
Omega 3 for Dogs Joint Support Soft Chews
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Calming Chews for Dogs - Holistic Ingredients, 90 Count
$15
Calming Chews for Dogs - Holistic Ingredients, 90 Count
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
8 pcs Protex Pawz Natural Rubber Waterproof Dog Boots - Large
$7
8 pcs Protex Pawz Natural Rubber Waterproof Dog Boots - Large
Lower East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Pawz Rubber Dog Boots - Small - Olive
Free
Pawz Rubber Dog Boots - Small - Olive
Midwood, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Buenkeee Dog Grooming Vacuum & Blow Dryer Kit
$100
Buenkeee Dog Grooming Vacuum & Blow Dryer Kit
Manhattan, NY
Karrot