Secondhand Pet Supplies in NYC & NJ (Page 6)

Browse secondhand pet supplies across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 503 listings with a median price of $20 (typical range $10–$45).

503 items
LeapFrog LeapTV Educational Gaming System Console with Games
$50
LeapFrog LeapTV Educational Gaming System Console with Games
Queens, NY
Karrot
Sherpa Everyday Dog & Cat Pet Carrier - Medium, Black
$4
Sherpa Everyday Dog & Cat Pet Carrier - Medium, Black
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Royal Canin Indoor Adult Cat Food - 7 lb
$24
Royal Canin Indoor Adult Cat Food - 7 lb
Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Hill's Prescription Diet Kidney + Mobility k/d j/d Dog Food
Free
Hill's Prescription Diet Kidney + Mobility k/d j/d Dog Food
Queens, NY
Karrot
58in Dark Gray Cat Tree, Never Opened
$65
58in Dark Gray Cat Tree, Never Opened
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Smart Automatic Self-Cleaning Litter Box for Cats
$109
Smart Automatic Self-Cleaning Litter Box for Cats
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Pet Honesty Hip + Joint Health Tumeric MSM Collagen 90 chews
$9
Pet Honesty Hip + Joint Health Tumeric MSM Collagen 90 chews
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Dogs Probiotic - Digestive Enzymes Promotes Gut Health
$23
Dogs Probiotic - Digestive Enzymes Promotes Gut Health
Coney Island, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Bunfly PET Grooming Kit QuiteVacuum + Trimmer, 16 Grooming Tools
$64
Bunfly PET Grooming Kit QuiteVacuum + Trimmer, 16 Grooming Tools
Mott Haven, The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Convertible Pet Stroller/Carrier
$80
Convertible Pet Stroller/Carrier
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot
Zapatos air Jordan retro 4 “black cat”. Niños/ mujer 4.5y
$108
Zapatos air Jordan retro 4 “black cat”. Niños/ mujer 4.5y
Richmond Hill, Queens, NY
Karrot
Bundle of 4 Dog Outfits
$15
Bundle of 4 Dog Outfits
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
TRIXIE “ Turn Around” Dog Puzzle
$6
TRIXIE “ Turn Around” Dog Puzzle
Upper East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Retractable Dog Leash with Waste Bags and Charger
$20
Retractable Dog Leash with Waste Bags and Charger
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Pet Harness and Leash Set with Nail Clippers
$36
Pet Harness and Leash Set with Nail Clippers
Queens, NY
Karrot
BARK Super Chewer I-Squeak Cone Dog Toy Medium-Large
$11
BARK Super Chewer I-Squeak Cone Dog Toy Medium-Large
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Cats Notecard Set
$4
Cats Notecard Set
Glendale, Queens, NY
Karrot
Paté food cat
Free
Paté food cat
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
GloFish Aquarium Starter Kit with Toys and Heater
$45
GloFish Aquarium Starter Kit with Toys and Heater
Queens, NY
Karrot
Wire Dog Crate with Pet Pad
$20
Wire Dog Crate with Pet Pad
Queens, NY
Karrot
White Faux Leather Cat Face Coin Purse with Strap
$25
White Faux Leather Cat Face Coin Purse with Strap
Queens, NY
Karrot
Cat tower
$10
Cat tower
Queens, NY
Karrot
Van Ness High Sides Cat Pan
Free
Van Ness High Sides Cat Pan
Yorkville, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Hyde and EEK! Boutique Chic & Cute Cat Mug
$10
Hyde and EEK! Boutique Chic & Cute Cat Mug
Morningside Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
LIKE NEW Dog Stairs / Pet Steps
$24
LIKE NEW Dog Stairs / Pet Steps
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Pet Honesty Hemp Calming Max Strength Duck Flavor BB 07/30/26
$9
Pet Honesty Hemp Calming Max Strength Duck Flavor BB 07/30/26
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
YOULY Dog Harness
$1
YOULY Dog Harness
Queens, NY
Karrot
Pete the Cat: Pete's Big Lunch
$3
Pete the Cat: Pete's Big Lunch
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Hill's Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin Dog Food
$52
Hill's Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin Dog Food
Murray Hill, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Greenies Original Dental Treats for Dogs, Large  🧡
$4
Greenies Original Dental Treats for Dogs, Large 🧡
Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Brand new Wireless Dog Fence System
$25
Brand new Wireless Dog Fence System
Whitestone, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet République Deshedding Tool
$4
Pet République Deshedding Tool
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Large Dog Bed
$15
Large Dog Bed
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Paramount+ Lioness Original Dog Tag Keychain
$5
Paramount+ Lioness Original Dog Tag Keychain
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Brown Leather Dog Collar and Leash Set
$15
Brown Leather Dog Collar and Leash Set
Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Kacoomi Pet Food and Water Dispenser Set
$10
Kacoomi Pet Food and Water Dispenser Set
Richmond Hill, Queens, NY
Karrot
Fold Your Own Paper Cats Origami Kit
$2
Fold Your Own Paper Cats Origami Kit
Queens, NY
Karrot
Large Wire Dog Crate
$150
Large Wire Dog Crate
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
PPC HSE KIT Coax Jumper & Cat 5e Jumper Kit
Free
PPC HSE KIT Coax Jumper & Cat 5e Jumper Kit
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Red Soft Dog Crate Carrier Pet Travel Kennel
$24
Red Soft Dog Crate Carrier Pet Travel Kennel
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot

Showing 1–240 of 503 items