Secondhand Pet Supplies in NYC & NJ (Page 7)

Browse secondhand pet supplies across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 503 listings with a median price of $20 (typical range $10–$45).

503 items
Green and Black Pet Carrier Bag
$11
Green and Black Pet Carrier Bag
New Dorp, Staten Island, NY
Karrot
Petflect Orange Reflective Dog Safety Vest
$5
Petflect Orange Reflective Dog Safety Vest
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Blue Dog House Playset with Plush Toy
$10
Blue Dog House Playset with Plush Toy
Queens, NY
Karrot
Air Dried Dog Food Toppers for Picky Eaters - Healthy Dog Treats
$14
Air Dried Dog Food Toppers for Picky Eaters - Healthy Dog Treats
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Crazy Cat Lady Cat Lovers 110 Cling Stickers Set
$8
Crazy Cat Lady Cat Lovers 110 Cling Stickers Set
Little Neck, Queens, NY
Karrot
Gray Wooden Multi-Level Pet Cage
$40
Gray Wooden Multi-Level Pet Cage
Queens, NY
Karrot
Collapsible Metal Dog Crate
$50
Collapsible Metal Dog Crate
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Funny Dog "Fetch This" Coffee Mug
$7
Funny Dog "Fetch This" Coffee Mug
Queens, NY
Karrot
WinWeal Soft Dog Cone Collar - Medium
$5
WinWeal Soft Dog Cone Collar - Medium
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Dog Crate for Small Dogs
$25
Dog Crate for Small Dogs
Queens, NY
Karrot
Vet's Choice Probiotic Chews for Dogs & Cats (Sample Pack x2)
$1
Vet's Choice Probiotic Chews for Dogs & Cats (Sample Pack x2)
Ridgewood, Queens, NY
Karrot
Brand new 2In1 Wireless Dog Collar Fence System
$20
Brand new 2In1 Wireless Dog Collar Fence System
Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Honesty Hemp Calming Max Strength 90 chews BB 7/31/26
$9
Pet Honesty Hemp Calming Max Strength 90 chews BB 7/31/26
Queens, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan 4 Retro Black Cat Size 10
$250
Air Jordan 4 Retro Black Cat Size 10
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Petique Trailblazer Pet Jogger - Blue Color
$160
Petique Trailblazer Pet Jogger - Blue Color
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Portable Dog Bath and Dog Carriage
$187
Portable Dog Bath and Dog Carriage
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Breeder's Edge Foster Care Kitten Milk Replacer 12 oz
$17
Breeder's Edge Foster Care Kitten Milk Replacer 12 oz
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Bell+Howell PawPerfect Pet Nail Trimmer
$14
Bell+Howell PawPerfect Pet Nail Trimmer
Bushwick, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Dog Treat Turbine
$9
Dog Treat Turbine
Lower East Side, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Free cat supplies
$5
Free cat supplies
Briarwood, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Water Fountain
$5
Pet Water Fountain
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Pillow Pets Triceratops Dream Lites night light
Free
Pillow Pets Triceratops Dream Lites night light
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot
8 Pete the Cat Educational Learning Posters Set
$25
8 Pete the Cat Educational Learning Posters Set
Astoria, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Gear
$12.60
Pet Gear
Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Pet Honesty Probiotics Gut+ Immune Health 180 Chews Pumpkin
$18
Pet Honesty Probiotics Gut+ Immune Health 180 Chews Pumpkin
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Molinta Washi PET Tape (Cut Stickers) Samples
$2
Molinta Washi PET Tape (Cut Stickers) Samples
Bayside, Queens, NY
Karrot
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin Adult Dog Food
$42
Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin Adult Dog Food
Long Island City, Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Stairs / Cat Steps
$22
Pet Stairs / Cat Steps
Bergen County, NJ
Karrot
Greenies Original TEENIE Dental Treats for Dogs
$10
Greenies Original TEENIE Dental Treats for Dogs
Queens, NY
Karrot
PetTemp Round Pet Heating Pad 16 Inch
$20
PetTemp Round Pet Heating Pad 16 Inch
Queens, NY
Karrot
Mount Dog Photography Lighting Kit with 2 Softboxes
$20
Mount Dog Photography Lighting Kit with 2 Softboxes
Midtown Manhattan, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
White Modular Pet Playpen Gate with Clear Panels
$60
White Modular Pet Playpen Gate with Clear Panels
Marine Park, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Black tote handbag with cat charm
$31
Black tote handbag with cat charm
Queens, NY
Karrot
Birdcage Table Lamp with Bird Accent
$20
Birdcage Table Lamp with Bird Accent
DUMBO, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Nature's Logic 100% All Natural Cat Litter
$10
Nature's Logic 100% All Natural Cat Litter
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Halloween Dog Toy Bundle - KONG, Thrills & Chills
$28
Halloween Dog Toy Bundle - KONG, Thrills & Chills
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Purina Fancy Feast Tender Beef & Liver Feast Cat Food
$10
Purina Fancy Feast Tender Beef & Liver Feast Cat Food
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Dog-Shaped Rhinestone Ring
$22
Dog-Shaped Rhinestone Ring
Morningside Heights, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Dermoscent Essential 6 Spot-On for Cats
$20
Dermoscent Essential 6 Spot-On for Cats
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Two-Tier Cat Bed Tower
$30
Two-Tier Cat Bed Tower
Flushing, Queens, NY
Karrot

Showing 1–280 of 503 items