Secondhand Pet Supplies in NYC & NJ (Page 12)

Browse secondhand pet supplies across NYC 5 boroughs and Northern NJ with zero fees. Currently tracking 503 listings with a median price of $20 (typical range $10–$45).

503 items
E.M&S.T Smart One & Cat Toothbrush Set
$4
E.M&S.T Smart One & Cat Toothbrush Set
Murray Hill, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Delectables Kitten Lickable Treat Bisque (2 pouches)
Free
Delectables Kitten Lickable Treat Bisque (2 pouches)
Bergen County, NJ
Karrot
NEW✨81-Piece Puzzle cat shape puzzle🧩
$5
NEW✨81-Piece Puzzle cat shape puzzle🧩
Midtown East, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Cat Scratcher Toy with Ball
Free
Cat Scratcher Toy with Ball
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Intelligentsia Black Cat Sublunar Coffee 12 oz
$10
Intelligentsia Black Cat Sublunar Coffee 12 oz
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Black Folding  Table (cat not included)
$10
Black Folding Table (cat not included)
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Wire Dog Crate with Tray
$17
Wire Dog Crate with Tray
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Dog Harness Front Clip Walking Adjustable
$15
Dog Harness Front Clip Walking Adjustable
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Pet Honesty Dogs Probiotic Chews - 90 ct
$28.95
Pet Honesty Dogs Probiotic Chews - 90 ct
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Dog cage
$40
Dog cage
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Zippy Paws Smartypaws Puzzler Fun Game for Dogs
$8
Zippy Paws Smartypaws Puzzler Fun Game for Dogs
Queens, NY
Karrot
Small dog crate
$20
Small dog crate
The Bronx, NY
Karrot
Dog cage
$50
Dog cage
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
6 new dvd's Dude, Where's My Dog? DVD
$24
6 new dvd's Dude, Where's My Dog? DVD
Queens, NY
Karrot
Eddie Bauer Puffer Dog Vest
$11
Eddie Bauer Puffer Dog Vest
Queens, NY
Karrot
New dog boots size 5 🥕
$8
New dog boots size 5 🥕
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Sporty Dog Hoodie Tracksuit  Athletic Puppy Outfit.
$10
Sporty Dog Hoodie Tracksuit Athletic Puppy Outfit.
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Mugobunni PET Tape Sample (Cut Stickers) $2
$2
Mugobunni PET Tape Sample (Cut Stickers) $2
Queens, NY
Karrot
Pet Playpen Black
$75
Pet Playpen Black
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Aesop Animal Pet Wash Shampoo 500ml / 16.9 fl oz - Brand New
$35
Aesop Animal Pet Wash Shampoo 500ml / 16.9 fl oz - Brand New
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Zuru my mini pets  para cambio
Free
Zuru my mini pets para cambio
Queens, NY
Karrot
Papier Platz PET Tape Sample (Cut stickers) $2
$2
Papier Platz PET Tape Sample (Cut stickers) $2
Queens, NY
Karrot
Plastic Pet Playpen
$32
Plastic Pet Playpen
Queens, NY
Karrot
Multi-Level Pet Cage
$56
Multi-Level Pet Cage
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Brown silicone pet Matt
$5
Brown silicone pet Matt
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Mamas & Papas Charlie Caterpillar Rocking Toy
$45
Mamas & Papas Charlie Caterpillar Rocking Toy
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
24.8" Tall Crystal Trumpet Vase Centerpiece
$36
24.8" Tall Crystal Trumpet Vase Centerpiece
Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Rifle Paper Co. Cat Mug with Gold Handle 🐱✨
$8
Rifle Paper Co. Cat Mug with Gold Handle 🐱✨
Queens, NY
Karrot
Air Jordan 4 Retro Black Cat
$80
Air Jordan 4 Retro Black Cat
Manhattan, NY
Karrot
CAT LINK Automatic Smart Cat Litter Box - Scooper Pro Ultra
$450
CAT LINK Automatic Smart Cat Litter Box - Scooper Pro Ultra
Downtown Brooklyn, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Pet carrier backpack
$22 Sold Out
Pet carrier backpack
Maspeth, Queens, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Epic Threads Girls & Cat & Jack 3T Tops  2 Pack
$3 Sold Out
Epic Threads Girls & Cat & Jack 3T Tops 2 Pack
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
California Costumes The Impawsters King of the Jungle Pet Mane 🏈
$15 Sold Out
California Costumes The Impawsters King of the Jungle Pet Mane 🏈
Harlem, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
🏈Lucky Cat Maneki Neko Leather Keychain
$15 Sold Out
🏈Lucky Cat Maneki Neko Leather Keychain
Midtown East, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Corduroy Dog Toy
$5 Sold Out
Corduroy Dog Toy
Woodside, Queens, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Purina Pro Plan FortiFlora Canine Probiotic Supplement  🏆
$6 Sold Out
Purina Pro Plan FortiFlora Canine Probiotic Supplement 🏆
Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grains Puppy Recipe
$13 Sold Out
Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grains Puppy Recipe
Queens, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Teenage white and black cat
Free Sold Out
Teenage white and black cat
Queens, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
Fisher-Price Sweet Snugapuppy Dreams Cradle 'n Swing
$52 Sold Out
Fisher-Price Sweet Snugapuppy Dreams Cradle 'n Swing
Queens, NY
Karrot
Sold Out
INABA Churu Tuna Creamy Cat Treats w/ Taurine
$17 Sold Out
INABA Churu Tuna Creamy Cat Treats w/ Taurine
Richmondtown, Staten Island, NY
Karrot